One of the biggest pitfalls I see leaders make is their inability to step away from their emotional responses before acting on them. A leaders emotional responses are not just personal, they are systemic. They influence relationships, reinforce patterns of behaviors and culture, and they impact people dynamics. Emotions are linked with the way we think and our cognitive interpretations of ourselves, others and the world around us. They are sense and meaning making experiences, and they invite us to interpret and create narratives around those interpretations. However, unexamined emotions are dangerous, they are lenses that have a direct impact on relationships and often don’t truly reflect the full story or reality. A leader must learn to separate their emotional experience from the thoughts and stories they construct before they make decisions or take actions.
Too often lead from their emotions, even those who say they don’t. Emotions are a key human experience, they are guides. While every emotion is valid, they are very often unreliable and tell us a range of stories that may not necessarily represent the whole truth. In over thirty years of working, studying leaders and being a leader, I find one of the biggest pitfalls is that leaders are often very much leading from their emotions, and find it very difficult to step away from their emotional responses long enough to make better decisions. This requires self-awareness, insight, maturity and discipline. Things that leaders are never taught or evaluated on.
Now that’s not to say that emotions are not important, we should embrace and understand emotions; where they come from; what they mean; how they invite is to think and act; how they impact our relationships and our bodies. Though we should never let them rule.
Our thoughts, feelings, physiological responses and our actions are all interconnected. Sometimes the cycles start with a thought, other times it starts with a feeling, sometimes it starts with noticing a physiological response, or we notice a thought or feeling that results from an action. Wherever the cycle starts for you, the emotion is a signal to pause and take a closer look. Decisions driven by emotion are very often the weakest decisions. A leader must learn to isolate and assess their knee-jerk emotional responses and take every thought captive before acting on it. A feeling is very rarely just a feeling in isolation. Similarly, a thought is very rarely just a. thought in isolation.
I once worked with a senior leader who felt that she could ay and do whatever she wanted, and that was mostly based on whatever she was experiencing emotionally that day. When the behavior and its impact on her team dynamics and relationships were addressed, she stated that they were just ‘throw away words”. She failed to see that for her team, they were deeply personal and meaningful, and they settled in the spaces between the relationship and festered until the working relationship became toxic, unsafe and untenable. There is no such thing as a ‘throw away’ word if you are a leader.
Leadership requires emotional discipline and maturity. It requires the ability to recognize what you are feeling, examine what is driving that response and separate your immediate emotional reaction from the decision that needs to be made.
Your emotions are important, but they are not authoritative
There is an important distinction between emotional awareness, emotional regulation and executive judgement.
Emotional awareness: Recognizing what you are experiencing, and why.
Emotional regulation: Developing the capacity to manage your response rather than react impulsively.
Executive judgement: Determining what action is appropriate, considering the wider relational and organizational system and the consequences for others.
From a systemic and narrative perspective, unexamined emotions can shape the stories we construct, the meaning we assign to others' behavior and the relationships and organizational dynamics we reinforce. Senior leaders must learn to create space between what they feel, what they think and how they choose to act.
Here are the facts:
Your emotions influence how you experience and interpret what is happening around you. When we don’t pause to reflect, we often find ourselves making dysfunctional assumptions or drawing conclusions that aren’t supported by the facts or the reality of the situation.
The way you think, feel and behave, all influence and are influenced by the broader system around you. As a leader, our response is never just our response, it is experienced first-hand by your team and clients. Emotional led decisions (particularly those more negative ones) have a much higher likelihood of damaging relationships, destroying trust, creating defensiveness, hurting cohesiveness and creating toxic working environments.
As a leader you are in a position of authority (and thus, accountability). A careless word, or thoughtless action driven by a temporary emotion has lasting relational and systemic impacts. Every word, action and emotional response you have has lasting downstream systemic impacts. Once you react, you can’t take it back. It is easier to withhold, than it is to clean up or mend.
Some easy ways to isolate those emotionally driven thoughts are:
Pause and reflect. Create a space between the emotion and any action. Nothing in business is truly urgent (unless you are saving lives), so create a gap between the thoughts and emotion, and your action/decision. Wait for the emotion to settle so you can evaluate your thoughts and actions.
Thoughts and emotions are linked, so take the time and assess these two things: Firstly, look at the thought that invited the emotion. Then secondly, look at the thought that the emotion invited. What do you notice? What are the triggers? What did it invite you to think or want to do? How did you interpret the feeling? what evidence supports that? What assumptions arose? What stories did you create? What are you actually responding to (your emotions or the situation)?
Finally, be deliberate in how you respond. You would be surprised that many leaders make knee-jerk reactions. They believe a fast response is leadership. It is not, it is leadership immaturity. Be deliberate in pausing and reflecting, and thinking through the impacts, and consequences and risks of those decisions and actions. Your decisions should be based on doing the right thing, integrity and values, not your temporary emotions. If you feel rushed, then that should be your first clue and red flag.
Take a moment to reflect:
In what ways are you able to recognize that your emotions are influencing your judgement and how you think?
How might you distinguish between your interpretation, rather than the meaning and interpretation you have assigned?
How might you identify the core beliefs that sit below the assumptions you make?
How often do you allow yourself time to pause and reflect, before responding?
What might change if you introduced this reflecting or thinking pause?
Which relationships have been damaged because you responded emotionally, or out of disappointment, frustration or anger? What can you do about it?
Do your emotional responses create a toxic work environment?
Do your emotional responses invite people to not trust you or to be defensive around you?
How often do you take accountability for the impact of your actions as a leader?
What stories have you created about situations, yourself or others based on thoughts and feelings? What is the evidence for those?
Emotions are key to the human experience, even at work, but as leaders, maturity requires us to be able to isolate those emotions temporarily to understand them and their impact so we can make better decisions. As leaders, we are accountable and expected to exercise patience, judgement, restraint and intentionality, and a care for those we lead. your emotions deserve attention as they directly impact your thoughts, actions and relationships.
Let's Get Connected
I am a Leadership Systems Advisor, researcher, and speaker who helps leaders make sense of the complex dynamics shaping organizational performance, culture, and leadership effectiveness. My work focuses on helping senior leaders understand the patterns, narratives, relationships, and structures influencing outcomes within their organizations.
Through a systems-informed and evidence-led approach, I help leaders move beyond surface-level solutions toward greater clarity, more effective decision-making, and more sustainable organizational change.
If you are navigating complexity, change, or transformation, I invite you to connect with me on LinkedIn and Instagram, where I share practical insights, research, and reflections on leadership systems, organizational culture, narrative leadership, complexity, communication, and change.
You can also subscribe to The Reflecting Leader newsletter for monthly insights on leadership, systems thinking, and the narratives shaping organizations. If you are ready to explore the patterns influencing your organization, learn more about my Leadership Systems Diagnostic Conversation through my website.